Excerpt: What is Pilates? What is Yoga? Why Can’t You Mix the Two?
Friday, September 11th, 2009Here are two short excerpts from a wonderful in-depth interview Michael Miller Pilates instructor carried out with the Pilates instructor and yoga practitioner, Claudio Fernandez, Rio de Janeiro on 4 December 2006.
The full interview is available for purchase as a nine-page PDF on the website, Michael Miller, hermit.com. I found the interview to an interesting exploration of Pilates, and Pilates and yoga.
Michael: What is Pilates?
Claudio: My English is bad, but I try. I believe that equality with you, Michael, that Pilates is the idea. That is, for me, first. Pilates is the idea. Because with this knowledge, you can do Pilates, Pilates, not real, like other Pilates exercises. You can train when you understand real Pilates Pilates is the idea. By the time you do a similar exercise based on Pilates, Pilates, but real that you experience in your body when you understand Pilates is the idea.
Michael: What is the idea?
Claudio: The idea is, in English, even the eccentric load flowing through progressive patterns of movement. This is the idea. This idea is equal to a mathematical formula, is very concise, very clear, very objective. Equal to a mathematical formula, when you understand the function, it is very easy, then apply the formula of any movement, because the area of knowledge of the formula is the movement.
Michael: The purpose of the formula is the movement.
Claudio: Yes. The equation in any kind of movement. Every move, no?
Michael: We used the formula of any kind of movement is that what you’re saying?
Claudio: Yes, very interesting, because when you understand Pilates as an idea, it is very easy to do Pilates. You know how to make connections, you know the function of each part of the training. Breathing, muscle twitching, time, parts of the movement. The formula is part of the motion and orders them. Because the form is an idea I like to talk about formula. Since an idea can be very broad, general idea, but a formula is an idea that is very specific, very specific, a formula is to shoot at a target. And the idea is very specific, clearly, its use is unclear.
Michael: What do you mean use it obvious?
Claudio: Using the body, it is clear the use of the body is the goal. The use of the body is the goal of the idea. Clearly this idea in your body specifically for the moving body.
Michael: The question is to move the body through space, right?
Claudio: Yes, this is the fundamental difference with Yoga. This is very, very important. Because the idea of Pilates is on the moving body, a predator, for survival. It’s the idea, survival is the evolution, because evolution makes survival. This is the power of the idea. The power of the idea is to make the movement in the body with more capacity.